Question regarding two versions of a page (redirect)
-
At one point in my SEO journey I had noticed some duplicate issues going on in Google webmaster tools (I could have been reading it wrong.)
It looked like WMT was saying I had 2 versions of some of pages...it looked like pages that ended in a '/' ranking differently than pages that have no slash at the end.
So I downloaded the redirect plugin and redirected many non / pages to the page that end with the "/". This was probably a mistake. but I'm trying to clean all of that up. (I'm also noticing that SEOMoz tools tells me my site has many, many redirected url's. I'm not sure why.
I was looking at http://www.opensiteexplorer.org/pages?site=noahsdad.com%2F this morning at my top pages and it shows 2 versions (one being redirected) of the page about my son who was born with Down syndrome. (Noahsdad.com/story and Noahsdad.com/story/) I don't know if I've built rankings for those pages separately and it would now hurt me if I did away with the redirect. I'm not sure why I did the redirects (I must have read something online somewhere.)
I'm wondering if someone wouldn't mind looking at the report and letting me know what the best way to 'clean' this stuff up...Should I go into the redirect software and delete all of the redirects where the non / page is being redirected to the / page?
Thanks.
-
You'll need to check the source code, as you'll be changing redirects rather than removing them, redirects will still be in place.
rel="canonical" href="http://noahsdad.com/story/" /> is a current Canonical.
rel="canonical" href="http://noahsdad.com/story" /> would be the new Canonical ( without the / )
-
Thanks!
So when I remove the redirect how can I check to make sure the new page gets the canonical? There will only be one page if I remove the redirect, right? So since it is just one page, wouldn't that page be the canonical?
-
Yep, some Canonical tags are being used. Will need to change the canonicals if you change your redirects ( removing the / ) unless it's automated that is.
Good luck with whatever you decide to do
-
Thanks. Like I said above I think my theme adds the canonical tag, because in the seo tools I can see many of links showing 'canonical.'
-
Using the / at the end when linking; if it matches the URL being linked to, then absolutely. If it differs to the URL being linked to, then it's linking to a different page essentially. Best to choose one method and to stick with it for consistency, whichever that ends up being. Usually, without the / is the better option.
You're right, with redirects, link juice is passed to the page being redirected to, however not 100% of it. Usually varies between 60% and 90%, as a guide, so some loss for sure.
With those new pages and redirects from last night; have you considered using the Canonical tag? Sounds like it's something that your website would benefit from using.
Here you'll find a **Guide to Canonical Tags**and here you'll find a Post & Discussion on 301 Redirects vs the Canonical tag which will explain everything you need to know about Canonicals.
Regards
Simon
-
I'm not sure. I believe the wordpress theme I have does this...
-
I was under the impression that it was always best to use the / at the end of the domain when linking, etc. Is this not the case?
Either way is fine. However, I choose to use the no "/" pages rather than the "/" pages. I do this because I get more links pointing at my site without the "/," and I want to retain as much link juice as possible.
Also, when you do a redirect I was under the impression that the link juice from the redirected page would be passed on to the page it is redirected to. Is this not the case?
A portion of it does pass. I've heard as high as 90% passes on.
I deleted some of those redirects but left the /down-syndrome-1 there...I have no idea how a url was generated with the -1 at the end, but it did. So i left it there (I may need to do something with that.)
Is it an exact duplicate of another page? If so, redirect.
Are you utilizing a "canonical" tag on the pages you want to be the "true" source? As it, using the "canonical" to say, "hey, this is the original!"
-
Thanks for the info, it helps a lot.
I was under the impression that it was always best to use the / at the end of the domain when linking, etc. Is this not the case?
When I go to my wordpress settings I see that under general settings my wordpress address and site address both have http://noahsdad.com (no slash) - just wanted to add that bit of info just in case it made any difference.
Also, when you do a redirect I was under the impression that the link juice from the redirected page would be passed on to the page it is redirected to. Is this not the case?
I made a change last night regarding a redirect to http://noahsdad.com/down-syndrome and http://noahsdad.com/down-syndrome-1 (both with and without the slash) I'm not sure if it was something with a slug I changed or something, but I had about 4 different redirects going to one page. I deleted some of those redirects but left the /down-syndrome-1 there...I have no idea how a url was generated with the -1 at the end, but it did. So i left it there (I may need to do something with that.)
-
Hi there,
You have a fab website dedicated to your son and his amazing progress, you must be very proud of the little chap.
Your question; there is some tidying up required moving forwards.
An example of a good redirect that you have is:
www.noahsdad.com/ is being 301'd to www.noahsdad.com
You apparently have 23 other pages being redirected from a version without / at the end to a version with / at the end, e.g. http://noahsdad.com/story 301'd to http://noahsdad.com/story/
The main issue with redirects this way round (non / pointing to a page with / at the end) is that with inbound links, the vast majority will point to pages without / at the end, so you'll be loosing some link juice through the redirects.
However, you already have many links pointing to your pages with a / at the end, some of this link juice would be lost if those pages are redirected. Though looking to the future, it could still be worth doing this sooner rather than later, so long as you try and request that your most valuable inbound links kindly have the / removed from the link, a time consuming process.
So an option is to remove the redirects that are in place, then 301 redirect the URLs with a / at the end to the corrosponding URLs without the / at the end.
You'll also need to update your sitemap.xml ( http://noahsdad.com/sitemap.xml ) to remove the / at the end of URLs once the 301 redirects are in place.
Over time, the URLs with a / at the end will disappear from search engine indexes.
So it's a calculated decision to make really, whether or not to change your Redirects around. It will likely result in some ranking drops (and more importantly, some visitor reduction) in the short-term, however would likely be more beneficial to do so in the medium & long term.
I hope that helps,
Regards
Simon
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How do I redirect SEO from pages on old website to new website with new domain name?
How do I redirect SEO from pages on old website to new website with new domain name? My website in squarespace has good rankings and we have rebranded to a new name and enw domain name, how do I move across the rankings fomr the old site in squarespace to my new site thats in wordpress please?
On-Page Optimization | | Carrotpower0 -
What to do about pages I have deleted?
I have been working through the dead links on my page and recreating the page with new content for those pages that it still makes sense to have on the site. But I have a few that were just changes of the title, spelling mistakes or other ways of saying the same thing In other words I created a page called "areas of the UK we cover" but decided to change it to "areas covered" However, I must have created links to this page and now it is a dead link with a page authority of 19 I think it would be spammy to have two pages, one called "areas covered" and the other called "areas of the UK we cover. It's not a disallow in Robots.txt because the page does not exist Please note I do not have access to the header to add code for a 301 redirect. I'm still using webs.com but not for new sites. I also have a page called singing telegrams london, that I changed from singagrams london. These are two words for the same thing but they are two very different keywords would it be ok to recreate this page and create content for singagrams london. Help is much appreciated
On-Page Optimization | | singingtelegramsuk0 -
Losing Page Rank
Hello Moz I launched a re-design of our site over the summer and we jumped in organic search for some keywords. Recently one of our landing pages is being hammered by Google last we we lost one position this week we lost 5 positions. Although, when I check the on-page grade Moz gives it an A is there a check sheet anyone has that I could go through to see if I have any common problems. Ryan
On-Page Optimization | | ryanparrish0 -
How to fix duplicate page content and page titles?
Apologies in advance if this has already been answered (it probably has) - I'm just not seeing it. Is there a guide on here for how to fix the issues brought up by the crawler - specifically, things like duplicate page content, or duplicate page titles? A lot of these seem to have been created by wordpress.org combos that I didn't anticipate - i.e., category pages, author pages, etc. The crawler brings up the problems, but I don' t know where to start to go about fixing them. Also, any guide on best SEO practices or fixing optimization problems, specifically for wordpress.org blogs, would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!
On-Page Optimization | | prospects1 -
What are the benefits of targeting one keyword phrase per page vs. multiple keywords per page
What are the benefits of optimizing a page for one keyword phrase versus a group of similar keywords, like this one that Rand posted on another blog entry http://bit.ly/7LzTxY: Ted Baker Ted Baker London Ted Baker Clothing Ted Baker Mens Ted Baker Mens Clothing Ted Baker Mens Collection
On-Page Optimization | | EricVallee340 -
Can I have a strong brand category page and a strong product page?
It seems Google base and other Comparison Shopping Engines like to see the brand in the product name. But, on my category page for that brand, website optimizer tells me including the brand name with each product is cannabilizes links. For example; I have a page for jewelerABC with 20 pieces of jewelry listed as well as original content about jewelerABC. I do not currently name these products as xyz by jewelerABC. This page comes up nicely in the serps. But in Google base The top listings for jewelry by jewelerABC seem to have every product named xyz by jewelerABC or JewelerABC xyzs. What is the best way to optimize.for both? Stephen
On-Page Optimization | | stephenfishman0