Homepage 302 redirect - Which option makes most sense?
-
Edit: Here's a simplified version of this issue and how I have fixed it thus far.
On AmbitionSnowskates.com, there is a video section. There is no content on this page, it 302 redirects to the newest video. If you access ambitionsnowskates.com/video/, you are redirected to ambitionsnowskates.com/video/safari-time/.
The original post (OP) was about a site with recurring events. There is a cycle between to which subpage the homepage should redirect. For this reason, I was wondering if I should redirect mysite.com to mysite.com/active-subpage/ or the other way around (and have the content directly on the homepage).
I was also wondering how this will affect the result in SERPs. It turns out Google shows the title and description of the destination page, but shows the URL of the original URL (the homepage).
Knowing this, I can tailor my meta descriptions to be about both the company and the current event; a mix of the two means I won't have to switch or duplicate meta descriptions between active events.
I do appreciate the real solution though: in my opinion there should be unique content on the homepage with according CTA. I'm trying to push this as the best fix, with redirections being an alternative, but albeit more complex, solution.
Again sorry for being so unclear. I wish I had had an example from the beginning.
I'm leaving this opened in case someone wants to chime in.
Ben
Hey guys, I need a hand on this one
We have a website with 3 events and we want the homepage to show the upcoming event.
- Event 1 is in February
- Event 2 is in April
- Event 3 is in June
These events are recurrent year after year.
Currently the homepage shows the content of event 1 at the root level (site.com/) . The other events have a unique URL (site.com/event-2, site.com/event-3).
Later in the year, after event 1 is over, we change the homepage content to event 2 and move event 1 to its own URL. In other words...
Current structure
Today:
- Event 1: site.com/
- Event 2: site.com/event-2
- Event 3: site.com/event-3
In March:
- Event 1: site.com/event-1
- Event 2: site.com/
- Event 3: site.com/event-3
And so on.
I want to make sure each event has its own URL and is properly indexed.
Option A
I can redirect the homepage to the right event: site.com -> 302 -> site.com/event-1.
If that's the way to go, what will be the SEO impact, i.e. what content will show up in SERPs? The destination page's content/meta description and title?
Option B
What I could also do is keep the current structure (content moved to the root), but redirect temporarily the event's unique URL to the homepage:
Today:
- Event 1: site.com/
- Event 1: site.com/event-1 -> 302 -> site.com/
- Event 2: site.com/event-2
- Event 3: site.com/event-3
In March:
- Event 1: site.com/event-1
- Event 2: site.com/
- Event 2: site.com/event-2 -> 302 -> site.com/
- Event 3: site.com/event-3
And so on.
Again, if that's the way to go, how will this impact SERPs, which title and description will I see for the homepage and individual events?
If you have other options, I'm all ears!
Thanks a lot! (I mean it)
-Ben
-
You really do not want to have a URL that is considered temporary unless you are changing domains or doing something like building a new website. From a search engine 1st perspective now if you want this thing to rank I think what you should do and tell me if I'm way off okay man is to use a landing page for instance go to http://www.blueprintmarketing.com then where you see the home button in navigation let your mouse hover over it. You will then see a drop down click on that it is a landing page. All landing pages is a separate way to add pages to your site that would work in this situation where you can keep the original site example.com and off of example.com you will not need any example.com/newevent you simply have the power with landing pages to turn them on and off what framework are you using for WordPress if you don't mind me asking?
-
Hey Thomas - we use Wordpress but we can customize it any way we like. I would guess the fix is plateform-agnostic though.
Indeed it would be easier to have CTAs on the homepage but that's not an option.
As far as rel=canonical, I wouldn't be comfortable instructing search engines that the homepage's canonical URL is an event's page, or instructing that an event's canonical URL is the homepage, because it isn't. Rel=canonical doesn't "fit" the temporary nature of the structure.
-
Yes we're OK with that.
-
so now is a rule of thumb you need a minimum of 300 words per page or blog post.
-
Hey Dave - we have a fair amount, enough to justify having distinct pages.
-
You need toKeep your homepage you need so it either has a update in the form of a call to action expressing the event or use landing pages
what platform are you working on don't let me ask asking? Is it WordPress, HTML?
try setting it up so you have one homepage that stays as your homepage in addition you will add landing pages that contain event information. Please look at the links below
http://unbounce.com/landing-pages/
http://www.copyblogger.com/landing-pages/
I hope this better answers your question. It is extremely hard to understand why you doubt rel=canonical it is one of the best ways to go about constructing a website. However if you are going to constantly be changing your homepage URL I think that is a terrible idea the one I say that I mean changing it like example.com/event-1 to example.com to example.com/event-5 that is what landing pages are for not redirects
sincerely,
Thomas
PS if you can take a screenshot or something that would be awesome
-
How much unique content is there on each event page?
-
I understand try https://www.optimizely.com/resources/multivariate-test-vs-ab-test
Hop it works,
Tom
-
There is only 1 domain (say www.site.com). I am looking to redirect pages within that domain, either from the homepage to an event page (www.site.com/my-event-1/), or from the event page to the homepage.
Redirecting seems like the right thing to do because I want to make sure each event has its own URL (maybe saying URI or slug is more correct).
I can't have 4 pages (1 per event) and the homepage with duplicate content. I don't think rel=canonical can help here, so my best bet is most likely redirections.
Does that clear it up a bit? I wish I could show an example but I can't, it's on a dev server.
-
Hi Ben,
it seems to me that you have quite a bit going on. Number 1 I would not start jumbling the domains around to redirect to each other I would use a simple system like event Brite its free and even SEOmoz uses it to create events. I would do this for each particular event and put it on the correct home page or website. just so you know what you described will most likely destroy any quality ranking that you have. Did you ask to do a 302 redirect because it is a temporary redirect? Please do not do what you have proposed for your own sake honestly you would be better off dating the link that you want indexed
so my site is example.com/event-12/2012/
may next website is example2.com/event-1/2013
and so on when you use a 302 redirect you completely stop any link juice or search engine good stuff from passing through your website to the next. It is very common to see a calendar with events set up and when they pass they are no longer worried about
to get the word out simply use
Each event will have its own indexed URL
PS 302 redirecting your website will not benefit you in any way you will not pass link juice and will honestly just put yourself through more work than needed.
If I understood you correctly this should be the correct answer. If I did not please let me know and I would like to help you whatever is wrong.
I apologize why is it that you have 3 websites?
Respectfully,
Thomas
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
302 > 302 > 301 Redirect Chain Issue & Advice
Hi everyone, I recently relaunched our website and everything went well. However, while checking site health, I found a new redirect chain issue (302 > 302 > 301 > 200) when the user requests the HTTP and non-www version of our URL. Here's what's happening: • 302 #1 -- http://domain.com/example/ 302 redirects to http://domain.com/PnVKV/example/ (the 5 characters in the appended "subfolder" are dynamic and change each time)
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Andrew_In_Search_of_Answers
• 302 #2 -- http://domain.com/PnVKV/example/ 302 redirects BACK to http://domain.com/example/
• 301 #1 -- http://domain.com/example/ 301 redirects to https://www.domain.com/example/ (as it should have done originally)
• 200 -- https://www.domain.com/example/ resolves properly We're hosted on AWS, and one of my cloud architects investigated and reported GoDaddy was causing the two 302s. That's backed up online by posts like https://stackoverflow.com/questions/46307518/random-5-alpha-character-path-appended-to-requests and https://www.godaddy.com/community/Managing-Domains/My-domain-name-not-resolving-correctly-6-random-characters-are/td-p/60782. I reached out to GoDaddy today, expecting them to say it wasn't a problem on their end, but they actually confirmed this was a known bug (as of September 2017) but there is no timeline for a fix. I asked the first rep I spoke with on the phone to send a summary, and here's what he provided in his own words: From the information gathered on my end and I was able to get from our advanced tech support team, the redirect issue is in a bug report and many examples have been logged with the help of customers, but no log will be made in this case due to the destination URL being met. Most issues being logged are site not resolving properly or resolving errors. I realize the redirect can cause SEO issues with the additional redirects occurring. Also no ETA has been logged for the issue being reported. I do feel for you since I now understand more the SEO issues it can cause. I myself will keep an eye out for the bug report and see if any progress is being made any info outside of this I will email you directly. Thanks. Issue being Experienced: Domains that are set to Go Daddy forwarding IPs may sometimes resolve to a url that has extra characters appended to the end of them. Example: domain1.com forwards to http://www.domain2.com/TLYEZ. However it should just forward to http://www.domain2.com. I think this answers what some Moz users may have been experiencing sporadically, especially this previous thread: https://mza.seotoolninja.com/community/q/forwarded-vanity-domains-suddenly-resolving-to-404-with-appended-url-s-ending-in-random-5-characters. My question: Given everything stated above and what we know about the impact of redirect chains on SEO, how severe should I rate this? I told my Director that I would recommend we move away from GoDaddy (something I don't want to do, but feel we _**have **_to do), but she viewed it as just another technical SEO issue and one that didn't necessarily need to be prioritized over others related to the relaunch. How would you respond in my shoes? On a scale of 1 to 10 (10 being the biggest), how big of a technical SEO is this? Would you make it a priority? At the very least, I thought the Moz community would benefit from the GoDaddy confirmation of this issue and knowing about the lack of an ETA on a fix. Thanks!0 -
301 redirect impact on ranking
If Website A is ranking 19th position in Google for a specific keyword, and Website B is ranking 30th position for the same keyword, What would be impact after 301 redirect? Will Website A drop to 30th position because of 301 or existing position would improve because of link juice?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | riyaaaz0 -
Internal links from homepage and other pages
Hello, I'm curious what the difference is between internal links from the homepage and category pages. Make it sense to give some internal links from category pages (with a high PA) to an another page for a boost in the search results? Or is the link value too low in this case? Thanks in advance,
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | MarcelMoz
Marcel1 -
303 redirect
Hi, 303 redirect is a good thing or not ? I have a homepage in 2 languages FR and EN > mywebsite.com/fr/ and mywebsite.com/en/. A 303 redirect is on mywebsite.com to mywebsite.com/fr/. Thanks D.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | android_lyon0 -
Primary Domain or Redirect?
We are starting a new travel guide for a resort town. I have bought an expired domain with decent related links and PR (which seems to have survived the transfer (4 months ago). Beofre we launch the new site I am trying to decide if we should use this expired domain as the primary URL for the new site or just do a permanent redirect and buy a new domain that better matches the theme of the site. I am obviously concerned with starting from scatch with a new domain. I am confident we can build some good rellevant links in a short time but this space is very competetive. Any input would be greatly appreciated.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Locals0 -
302 Redirect of www. version of a site - Pros/Cons
Hi, I am considering making the 301 redirect from the domain to a 302 temporary redirect. Currently if a user lands on "www" version of the site, they are redirected to the non "www" version. But after the redirect, they will land on an external webpage (so if a user lands on the "www" version, they are redirected to a different website, not related to my domain). Reason I'm considering this is because I have received a large number of spammy backlinks on the "www" version of the site (negative seo). So I'm hoping that the temporary redirect will help me recover. Your thoughts on this: 1. Is this the best way to do a 302 redirect (redirecting the www version to an external domain)? 2. Will the redirect help the main domain recover, considering all spammy backlinks are pointing to the www version? 3. What are the pros/cons, if any? Thanks in advance for your thoughts! Howard
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | howardd0 -
Should I start new domain and redirect site?
I recently my rankings for http://www.top-10-dating-reviews.com (some adult content) drop off a cliff. Google tells me there's no manual penalty therefore it might be algorithmic. I don't know why my rankings went but I think it could be that I added A LOT of category pages pulling the same content from posts and this could have caused both duplicate content issues and too many on page links causing an algo penalty. Ive deleted the categories and therefore fixed duplicate content issue (perhaps you guys could check out the site and see that you agree with me) but rankings have not improved even thougo most of the pages have been recrawled. I read somewhere its extremely hard to recover from such a penalty so should I move my site to a and domain and redirect all urls? I can't think of another solution. Any help appreciated!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | SamCUK0 -
Does this make sense to recover from panda?
Hello guys, our website was pandalized on 9/27/2012 and we haven't been able to recover since then. I've fixed as much as possible when it comes to poor content, and we have been getting high quality links consistently for the past 3-4 months. Our blog had some duplicate content issues due to categories, tags, feeds, etc. I solved those problems before the past 2 refreshes without success. I'm considering moving the blog to a subdomain, more than PR, I'm interested in recovering from panda, and let the blog grow on its own. What do you think about that?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | DaveMri0