Why has my site dropped to page 2?
-
I haven't been paying attention to my sites SERP for the past year, and only realized I've dropped to page 2 on a keyword search.
Specifically, on Google.ca, searching the keywords "wedding invitations"
My site, www.stephita.com, used to consistently rank in the top 3 links. While my competitors have leapfrogged me.
I realized that my site wasn't "mobile-friendly", and had a few other issues like keyword stuffing, long meta descriptions and titles. I've fixed these issues "now", but wanted to know does this mean my site was severely penalized by the Panda/Penguin updates for the last few years?
Does having a PR3 site mean anything? My competitors who our rank me on SERP, are all PR1 sites.
Greatly appreciate any feedback you can give me!
-
Yes, I've removed all the "shortcuts" of bad thin content now.
But I'm a little confused by your comment:
But anyone who looks closely at these cookie cutter pages will see that the wording is awkward, the photos don't match the names or the colors listed, and problems like Oren & Bar Mitzvah sneak in.
Do you see something in particular that is bringing this to your attention?
-
When a site is hit by Panda, most pages of the site suffer a rankings decline. There are different levels of Panda severity. Sometimes the losses might be just a couple of positions, other times the losses might drop many positions.
You seem to have a nice business and you've gotten away with using shortcuts to create your content for a while. But anyone who looks closely at these cookie cutter pages will see that the wording is awkward, the photos don't match the names or the colors listed, and problems like Oren & Bar Mitzvah sneak in.
It's time to invest the time needed to do a proper job. That's what most people who have Panda problems and want to get out of them are doing.
-
As always, I appreciate your knowledgeable feedback on these issues.
I'm cleaning up my site, and removing some of the 'black-hat' SEO techniques that I had thought worked 5 years ago... I had created a script to generate "doorway" pages on my site.
i.e., if you searched "wedding invitations" + random city, like "wedding invitations thornhill, wedding invitations richmond hill, wedding invitations brampton, etc...
http://www.stephita.com/wedding/invitations/thornhill
http://www.stephita.com/wedding/invitations/richmond+hill
http://www.stephita.com/wedding/invitations/brampton
My site is listed on the first page for most of these "wedding invitation city" type searches.
Assuming my site has already been "Panda Demoted", does it make sense that these links are still on the first page for those "long tail searches"? Is it because of these specific pages that my site's index page (www.stephita.com) has been demoted in SERP when searching for the broader "wedding invitations" locally? ** I hope I am making sense here **
I used to have links in the footer and sitemap that would lead crawlers to these "doorway pages", but I have removed all traces of it from the site now. How long will the pre-existing indexed pages live in their results? Should I take steps to pro-actively remove them?
-
Is it re-calculated daily, or only when there are Panda updates (how often?)?
Nobody knows how often google injects new Panda evaluations into the ranking results. It's really irrelevant because the sooner you improve the content of your website the sooner your visitors will have a quality experience. Thin pages can produce a negative impression of your business on the visitor, especially when your competitors have done an excellent job.
**I'm just thinking in the case where I create 1000 product display pages, does that mean I would really need to write 1000 content HEAVY pages? **
Generous content is the cost of becoming competitive. The fact that you realize that and make it happen gives you a huge advantage over your competitors.
**If my site is built 80% product pages, and I suddenly add the NOINDEX meta tag, will that negatively impact the result? **
Nobody really knows the answer to this. If I had a site that was 80% thin product pages, I would delete them instead of noindexing such a large part of the site. Each time you improve one into a good substantive page and publish it, that page will become and asset that pulls traffic and converts visitors.
Is there a "magic number" of number of words to make it a suitable content page?
Since you have a walk-in store, you probably have a lot of experience with customers. Take that experience and produce a page that explains the product, answers common questions, counters objections, explains the questions that they should have asked but didn't.
My main focus for any searchers is to reach my main index page.
I don't agree with that goal. Most of the people who purchase from my sites never see the homepage. They land on a product page from search and add an item to the cart. They might land on an article that I have written and use a house ad or a link to my store and then buy the product. I am quite confident that if many of these customers landed on naked pages I would have never gotten their business.
-
If you remove all your thin content you are sure to bypass panda and you wouldn't be penalized.
And there aren't really a magic number of number of words to make a suitable content page but make sure that the html and content ratio is 70% to 30%.
-
I'll make an effort to improve the THIN content pages. Assuming I've "fixed" all issues that the Panda Algo doesn't like - how "soon/long" would it take to be "out of demotion". Is it re-calculated daily, or only when there are Panda updates (how often?)?
Is there anyway to flag a "product page" so that Panda wouldn't look at it? I'm just thinking in the case where I create 1000 product display pages, does that mean I would really need to write 1000 content HEAVY pages? -- Sorry, I just realized there is the META NOINDEX method...
If my site is built 80% product pages, and I suddenly add the NOINDEX meta tag, will that negatively impact the result? Or would that benefit me in this situation? It was never my intention for any searchers to land on any direct product page. My main focus for any searchers is to reach my main index page.
Is there a "magic number" of number of words to make it a suitable content page? (i.e. NOT-THIN)
I really appreciate you helping me out with this!
-
Would Google penalize me for having THIN content then?
I would be very surprised if your site does not currently have a Panda demotion. Most of the links in your persistent navigation lead to thin content. If you decide to improve these pages it is really important that the content be unique, very different from page to page and substantive.
Another method of escaping Panda is to remove thin content from the site. Here is an article by Marie Haynes that explains how a couple sites improved after thin content removal.
Lastly, does PageRank matter anymore? My site was a PR3 - does that matter when the other local competitors that have leapfrogged me are all PR1s?
PageRank can be important. However, your search results are heavily influenced by the geographic location of the searcher and their distance from your location.
If I owned your site, my priorities would be to improve it by a combination of content writing and thin content removal, then put my main effort into optimizing and promoting my site for local search.
-
Thanks for giving me a better understanding of how Panda works.
I agree, I'm targeting my local market, but I noticed when using "google.ca" (vs. .com) Searching for the keywords "wedding invitations" (without Toronto), does yield a few of my local competitors (along with the big boys like vistaprint) that have leapfrogged me this past year....
So if my site had, hypothetically speaking, 1000s of product pages, but with a simple one line description, along with photo and price to be simple. Would Google penalize me for having THIN content then?
Lastly, does PageRank matter anymore? My site was a PR3 - does that matter when the other local competitors that have leapfrogged me are all PR1s?
-
Panada is a part of the Google algorithm that looks at the quality of a website. If a website has lots of duplicate pages or thin content pages then Google will demote the rankings of the entire website.
Google's recommended way of fixing the problem is to improve the content of those pages by adding substantive, relevant, unique content that is useful for the visitors. You could easily do this for your site. It will simply take a dedicated effort to improve those pages.
Will that enable you to compete effectively with vistaprint, etsy, partycity and others? I am not optimistic it will.
However, you might be able to optimize and promote your site so that it appears in local searches such as "toronto wedding invitations". I see you on the first page, but with some work and investment you might be able to get a better position on both the page and the map results.
-
Thanks for your feedback!
Yes, I agree, I feel that my page 1 placement was more due to my searches based on my geographic location. That is my biggest concern at the moment, that other customers in my area are not finding my site anymore.
I'll definitely remove those footer links that serve very little purpose other than to direct users to content that they can get from the main navigation.
To get a better idea of how Panda works, or Google Search Algo in general... does it look at my site as a "whole" when it scores the value of sending users to my index page?
For pages on my site that obviously are only meant as a "product" with simple photo, sku and price. Does that mean it would see it as very thin content, and penalize my site as a whole?
-
The query "wedding invitations" is quite competitive.
If I look at the .ca SERPs I see well-known, highly deserving, world class brands at the top such as vistaprint, etsy, zazzle, partycity.
Your site is on page three for me.
Perhaps when you searched in the past, Google delivered some personalized SERPs on the basis of your past browsing history or on the basis of your geographic location.
Is your site penalized? It would not surprise me if you have a Panda problem. There are a lot of thin content pages on your site. Clicking on the keyword links in the footer of the site yields pages with an image, a name, and really nothing more. Many of the links in the top navigation produce pages that are about the same. If you don't have a Panda problem yet, you will probably have one soon.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Which URL and rel=canonical structure to use for location based product inventory pages?
I am working on an automotive retailer site that displays local car inventory in nearby dealerships based on location. Within the site, a zip code is required to search, and the car inventory is displayed in a typical product list that can be filtered and sorted by the searcher to fit the searchers needs. We would like to structure these product inventory list pages that are based on location to give the best chance at ranking, if not now, further down the road when we have built up more authority to compete with the big dogs in SERP like AutoTrader.com, TrueCar.com, etc. These higher authority sites are able to rank their location based car inventory pages on the first page consistently across all makes and models. For example, searching the term "new nissan rogue" in the Los Angeles, CA area returns a few location based inventory pages on page 1. The sites in the industry that are able to rank their inventory pages will display a relatively clean looking URL with no redirect that still displays the local inventory like this in the SERP:
Local Website Optimization | | tdastru
https://www.autotrader.com/cars-for-sale/New+Cars/Nissan/Rogue
but almost always use a rel=canonical tag within the page to a page with a location parameter attached to the end of the URL like this one:
https://www.autotrader.com/cars-for-sale/New+Cars/Nissan/Rogue/Los+Angeles+CA-90001"/>
I'm having a hard time figuring out why sites like this example have their URLs and pages structured this way. What would be the best practice for structuring the URL and rel=canonical tags to be able to rank for and display location based inventory pages for cars near the searcher?0 -
I have a Wordpress site that ranks well and a blog (uses blogger) with slightly different URL/domain that also ranks decently. Should I combine the 2 under the website domain or keep both?
I realize that I am building essentially 2 different sites even though they are connected, but on some local town pages i have 2-3 results on Page #1. Nice problem to have eh? But i am worried as for a lot of my surrounding towns my competitor has the top listing or definitely ahead of me, so i am wondering if i combine or convert my blog into the same domain as my site, then all of that content + links should hopefully propel my site to #1. Anyone have an experience like this? thanks, Chris
Local Website Optimization | | Sundance_Kidd0 -
Does multiple sites that relate to one company hurt seo
I know this has been asked and answered but my situation is a little different. I am a local electrical contractor. I specialize in a service and not a product. Competition is high in the local market due to the other electrical contractors that have well seasoned sites with very good DA/PA. Although new to the web I am not new to the trade. Throughout years almost back to the AOL dialup days I have been collecting domain names for this particular purpose. Now I want to put them to good use. Being an electrical contractor, there are many different facets of work and services we provide. My primary site is empireelec.com A second site I threw online overnight with minimal content is jacksonvillelightingrepair.com. Although it is a fresh site, there is minimal content and I have put almost zero effort in to it. It appears to be ranking for keywords a lot quicker. That leads me to believe I should utilize my other domain jacksonvillefloridaelectrician.com and target just the keyword Jacksonville Florida Electrician. It leads me to believe I should use jacksonvillebeachelectrician.com for targeting electricians in jacksonville beach. And again with jacksonvilleelectricianservice.com I can provide a unique phone number for each site. Am I going about this all wrong? Everything I read says no,no,no but I feel my situation is a little more unique.
Local Website Optimization | | empireelec1 -
Sub domain for geo pages
Hello Group! I have been tossing the idea in my head of using sub domains for the geo pages for each of my clients. For example: one of my clients is a lawyer in a very competitive Atlanta market http://bestdefensega.com. Can I set his geo page to woodstock.bestdefensega.com? Is this a viable option? Will I get penalized? Thoughts or suggestions always appreciated! Thanks in Advance
Local Website Optimization | | underdogmike0 -
How can i optimize my pages for local areas if we are not in that area?
Hi Mozers! So I watched a video about Matt Cutts he talks about creating multiple web pages just for one keywords is an absolutely no go. So I was wondering we serve a clients in NZ Australia and USA, If we target phrase like Psychic Readings California, Psychic Readings San Diego etc (USA) Psychic Readings Melbourne, Psychic Readings Sydney (AU) Psychic Readings Auckland, Psychic Readings Wellington (NZ) What is the best practice or right way to go about structuring my pages to do this without going against googles guidelines. Many thanks
Local Website Optimization | | edward-may1 -
Local SEO: City & County Pages
I'm working on developing some local pages for an HVAC company. They cover two counties, so I was planning on having two county pages, then linking them to individual city pages to keep the menu simpler and not cluttering it up with a couple dozen city pages for people to slog through. Has anybody ever done county pages before for local SEO? Or at least seen them? Just curious to see if there's any real benefit overall for have separate county pages, or if I should just stick to city pages.
Local Website Optimization | | ChaseMG0 -
Massive drop in traffic, recently.
We have been focusing on Local SEO and quality, original content and social media. Over the past 4 weeks we have seen sharp declines in our impressions and overall traffic to the site. Crawler does not reveal any new massive issues, index is growing and there are no penalties. Where do we begin to troubleshoot?
Local Website Optimization | | GreenStone0 -
Can to many 301 redirects damage my Ecommerce Site - SEO Issue
Hello All, I have an eCommerce website doing online hire. We operate from a large number of locations (100 approx) and my 100 or so categories have individual locations pages against them example - Carpet Cleaners (category) www.mysite/hire-carpetcleaners
Local Website Optimization | | PeteC12
carpet cleaner hire Manchester www.mysite/hire-carpetcleaners/Manchester
carpet cleaner hire london
carpet cleaner hire Liverpool patio heater (category)
patio heater hire Manchester
patio heater hire London
patio heater hire Liverpool And so on..... I have unique content for some of these pages but given that my site had 40,000 odd urls, I do have a large amount of thin/duplicate content and it's financially not possible to get unique
content written for every single page for all my locations and categories. Historically, I used to rank very well for these location pages although this year, things have dropped off and recently , I was hit with the Panda 4.0 update which i understand targets thin content. Therefore what I am int he process of doing is reducing the number of locations I want to rank for and have pages for thus allowing me to achieve both a higher percentage of unique content over duplicate/thin content on the whole site and only concerntrate on a handful of locations which I can realistically get unique content written for. My questions are as follows. By reducing the number of locations, my website will currently 301 redirect these location page i have been dropping back to it's parent category.
e.g carpet cleaner hire Liverpool page - Will redirect back to the parent Carpet cleaner hire Page. Given that I have nearly 100 categories to do , this will mean site will generate thousands of 301 redirects when I reduce down to a handful of locations per category. The alternative Is that I can 404 those pages ?... What do yout think I should do ?.. Will it harm me by having so many 301's . It's essentially the same page with a location name in it redirecting back to the parent. Some of these do have unqiue content but most dont ?. My other question is - On a some of these categories with location pages, I currently rank very well for locally although there is no real traffic for these location based keywords (using keyword planner). Shall I bin them or keep them? Lastly , Once I have reduced the number of location pages , I will still have thin content until , I can get the unique content written for them. Should I remove these pages until that point of leave them as it is? It will take a few months
to get all the site with unique content. Once complete, I should be able to reduce my site down from 40,000 odd pages to say 5,000 pages Any advice would be greatly appreciated thanks
Pete0