Is robots.txt a must-have for 150 page well-structured site?
-
By looking in my logs I see dozens of 404 errors each day from different bots trying to load robots.txt. I have a small site (150 pages) with clean navigation that allows the bots to index the whole site (which they are doing). There are no secret areas I don't want the bots to find (the secret areas are behind a Login so the bots won't see them).
I have used rel=nofollow for internal links that point to my Login page.
Is there any reason to include a generic robots.txt file that contains "user-agent: *"?
I have a minor reason: to stop getting 404 errors and clean up my error logs so I can find other issues that may exist. But I'm wondering if not having a robots.txt file is the same as some default blank file (or 1-line file giving all bots all access)?
-
Thanks, Keri. No, it's a hand-built blog. No CMS.
I think the googlebot is doing a good job of indexing my site. The site is small and when I search for my content I do find it in google. I was pretty sure that google worked the way you describe. So it sounds like sitemaps are an optional hint, and perhaps not needed for relatively small sites (couple hundred pages of well linked content). Thanks.
-
The phrase "blog entries" makes me ask are you on a CMS like Wordpress, or are the blog entries pages you are creating from scratch?
If you're on WP or a CMS, you'll want a robots.txt so that your admin, plugin, and other directories aren't indexed. On the plus side, WP (and other CMSs) have plugins that will generate a sitemap.xml file you as you add pages.
Google will find pages if you don't have a site map, or forget to add them. The sitemap is a way to let Google know what is out there, but it a) isn't required for Google to index a page and b) won't force Google to index a page.
-
Thanks, Keith. Makes sense.
So how important is an xml sitemap for a 150 page site with clean navigation? As near as I can tell (from the site: command) my whole site is already being indexed by Google. Does a sitemap buy me anything? What happens if my sitemap is partial (ie if I forget to add new pages to it, but I do link to the new pages from my other indexed pages, then will the new pages get indexed)? I'm a little worried about sitemap maintenance as I add new blog entries and so on...
-
Hi Mike...
I am sure that you are always going to get a range of opinions to this kind of question.
I think that for your site the answer may be simply that having a robots.txt file is more of a “belt and braces” safe harbour-type thing – the same goes for say whether you should have a keywords meta tag – many say these pieces of code can be of marginal value but, when you are competing head to head for a #1 listing (ie 35%+ of the clicks) then you should use every option and weapon possible ...furthermore, if your site is likely to grow significantly or eventually have content/files that you may want excluded, it’s just a “tidy” thing to have had indexed over time.
Also, don’t forget that best practice robots.txt file taxonomy is to also include directions to your xml sitemap/s.
Here is an example from one of our sites...
User-agent: *
Disallow: /design_examples.xml
Disallow: /case_studies.xmlUser-agent: Googlebot-Image
Disallow: /Sitemap: http://www.sitetopleveldomain.com/sitemap.xml
In this example there are two root files specifically excluded from all bots and this site has also specifically excluded the Google Images bot as they were getting a lot of traffic from image searches and then subsequently seeing the same copyright images turn up on a hundred junk sites – this doesn’t stop image scraping but certainly reduces the ease of finding them.
In relation to the “or 1-line file giving all bots all access” part of your question...
Some bots (most notably Google) now support an additional field called "Allow:"
As the name suggests, "Allow:" lets you specifically indicate what files/folders CAN be crawled, excluding all others. However, this field is currently not part of the "robots.txt" protocol and so not universally supported, so my suggestion would be to test it for your site for a week, as it might confuse some less intelligent crawlers.
So, in summary, my recommendation is to keep a simple robots.txt file, test if the Allow: field works for you and also ensure you have that guide to your xml sitemap – although wearing a belt and braces might not be a good look, at least your pants are unlikely to fall down
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Sitemap: Linking horizontal pages on a sitemap that has a vertical hierarchy structure
I'm currently in the process of revamping a website and creating a sitemap for it so that all pages get indexed by search engines. The site is divided into two websites that share the same root domain. The marketing site is on example.com and the application is on go.example.com. To get to go.example.com from example.com, you need to go through one of three “action pages”. The action pages are accessed from every page on example.com where we have a CTA button on the site (that’s pretty much every page). These action pages do not link back to any other page on the site though, nor are they a necessary step to navigate to other webpages. These action pages are only viewed when a user is ready to be taken to the application site. My question is, how should these pages be set up in a vertical sitemap since these three pages have a horizontal structure? Any insight would be much appreciated!
Technical SEO | | RallyUp0 -
How to stop crawls for product review pages? Volusion site
Hi guys, I have a new Volusion website. the template we are using has its own product review page for EVERY product i sell (1500+) When a customer purchases a product a week later they receive a link back to review the product. This link sends them to my site, but its own individual page strictly for reviewing the product. (As oppose to a page like amazon, where you review the product on the same page as the actual listing.) **This is creating countless "duplicate content" and missing "title" errors. What is the most effective way to block a bot from crawling all these pages? Via robots txt.? a meta tag? ** Here's the catch, i do not have access to every individual review page, so i think it will need to be blocked by a robot txt file? What code will i need to implement? i need to do this on my admin side for the site? Do i also have to do something on the Google analytics side to tell google about the crawl block? Note: the individual URLs for these pages end with: *****.com/ReviewNew.asp?ProductCode=458VB Can i create a block for all url's that end with /ReviewNew.asp etc. etc.? Thanks! Pardon my ignorance. Learning slowly, loving MOZ community 😃 1354bdae458d2cfe44e0a705c4ec38dd
Technical SEO | | Jerrion0 -
Robots.txt
Hello, My client has a robots.txt file which says this: User-agent: * Crawl-delay: 2 I put it through a robots checker which said that it must have a **disallow command**. So should it say this: User-agent: * Disallow: crawl-delay: 2 What effect (if any) would not having a disallow command make? Thanks
Technical SEO | | AL123al0 -
Discontinuing a site & Redirecting Traffic to an Internal Page
We are wondering the best way to redirect the traffic from a site that will no longer exist. The Scenario:
Technical SEO | | TopFloor
Our client wants to discontinue this website http://www.animalcarepackaging.com/. We’d like to redirect the traffic from this site to an internal page on our client's other website: http://www.glenroy.com/packaging/. This internal page is the most appropriate to the content that appears on animalcarepackaging.com (as opposed to just the entire site glenroy.com). Possible Options We Are Considering:
Option 1: Keep hosting animalcarepackaging.com and add a 301 redirect for all pages to glenroy.com/packaging/. Our concern with this option is that Google/Bing will see animalcarepackaging.com as a gateway, which could hurt glenroy.com. Option 2: Keep hosting animalcarepackaging.com and add a 301 redirect so all pages are sent to glenroy.com/packaging/; AND file a change of address with Google and Bing. We believe this will allow people who have bookmarked animalcarepackaging.com to go to glenroy.com/packaging/; while people searching for animalcarepackaging.com will go to glenroy.com's home page. We would augment this by posting a message on the homepage of animalcarepackaging.com notifiying users that the site will be discontinued and info will be found at glenroy.com/packaging. Option 3: Do a change of address with Google/Bing and send all traffic to glenroy.com (rather than an internal page). Post information on the homepage of animalcarepackaging.com that the site will be discontinued on X-date, and info about animalcarepackaging.com will be able to be found at glenroy.com/packaging. Looking for feedback on our options and suggestions on how this can be handled.0 -
Do i have my robots.txt file set up properly
Hi, just doing some seo on my site and i am not sure if i have my robots file set correctly. i use joomla and my website is www.in2town.co.uk. here is my robots file, does this look correct to you User-agent: *
Technical SEO | | ClaireH-184886
Disallow: /administrator/
Disallow: /cache/
Disallow: /components/
Disallow: /includes/
Disallow: /installation/
Disallow: /language/
Disallow: /libraries/
Disallow: /media/
Disallow: /modules/
Disallow: /plugins/
Disallow: /templates/
Disallow: /tmp/
Disallow: /xmlrpc/ many thanks1 -
150 products 301 redirect to HOME page, any impact?
If redirect 150 products to the home page, will I be penalize? It does not look like I can have access to cPanel on this platform, BigCommerce and i moves my old domain to this plateforme, the only option I might have his to redirect everythings to home page. Thank you, BigBlaze
Technical SEO | | BigBlaze2050 -
ECommerce site - Duplicate pages problem.
We have an eCommerce site with multiple products being displayed on a number of pages. We use rel="next" and rel="prev" and have a display ALL which I understand Google should automatically be able to find. Should we also being using a Canonical tag as well to tell google to give authority to the first page or the All Pages. Or was the use of the next and prev rel tags that we currently do adequate. We currently display 20 products per page, we were thinking of increasing this to make fewer pages but they would be better as this which would make some later product pages redundant . If we add 301 redirects on the redundant pages, does anyone know of the sort of impact this might cause to traffic and seo ?. General thoughts if anyone has similar problems welcome
Technical SEO | | SarahCollins0 -
Subdomain Robots.txt
If I have a subdomain (a blog) that is having tags and categories indexed when they should not be, because they are creating duplicate content. Can I block them using a robots.txt file? Can I/do I need to have a separate robots file for my subdomain? If so, how would I format it? Do I need to specify that it is a subdomain robots file, or will the search engines automatically pick this up? Thanks!
Technical SEO | | JohnECF0