Panda Or Penguin Hit ?
-
Hi,
My site was hit in april and did get a warning message in wmt for unnatural links , so i removed links and filed a reconsideration request , google then revoked the penalty .
that was june , the site still has not recovered and thinking maybe i was hit by both panda and penguin , at that time i did not have analytics installed was using awstats .
I have attached awstats for april So you can see when the traffic drop started .
So was i hit by panda , penguin or both ?
-
Panda is about a lot more than just ads on the website - it involves quite a few factors related to the quality of the content on a website (having too many ads is one of the factors).
Here is a blog post from Google listing some quality factors related to Panda: http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2011/05/more-guidance-on-building-high-quality.html
-
Hey Dean
If you really want to review this in earnest you need to go back to Feb 2011 and start reviewing things from there. Check for traffic drops that correspond with known updates to Penguin and Panda which you can get from here:
http://www.seomoz.org/google-algorithm-change
Then, you also need to compare this against the time you got the email from webmaster tools stating there was a manual penalty (which, of course is in addition to any Penguin and Panda issues).
So, resolving a Manual penalty is pretty tough so if you have sorted that, odds are you have got rid of a bunch of the bad links so may well have cleared up any Penguin issues but you really need to review the affected keywords and make double sure.
First step, check all the dates you lost traffic to get an idea of what your problems are then use that information to guide your hand going forward.
From our experience helping people with various penalties we can generally recover specific keywords by fixing the anchor text and we can recover some traffic with Panda penalties but reports of people recovering in entirety are thin on the ground (WPMU is the only one that springs to mind).
Ultimately, if you picked up a Penguin, Panda and Manual Penalty this year, then you probably have a whole bunch of problems that you need to review that go beyond trying to resolve the actual penalty issues.
Some useful further reading:
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/fat-pandas-and-thin-content
http://www.bowlerhat.co.uk/blog/penguin-diagnosis-and-recovery-strategy/
If you want more feedback and anything more than just a generic overview we would really require a link so we can take a look at the site itself.
Sure hope this helps though!
Marcus
-
I am pretty sure that you have been hit by Penguin, I have the same traffic drop approximately at same dates. (24-25 of april)
Even if Google revoked penalty it doesn't meen that your rankings will return.
At the the time you need to understand how Google filters work:
Penguin is all about wrong on-page optimisation and unnatural linkbuilding! Don't buy from link farms and etc.
Panda is all about ads on website.
Thanks
Russel
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
PDF web traffic hitting our site
Hi there, Over the last few months our traffic has spiked due to irrelevant pdf documents sending us crap traffic, our bounce rate is sky high as well as other metrics. I don't want to just filter out this traffic in GA rather try and stop our site from being attacked. Any advice on a way forward would be great. Thanks
Reporting & Analytics | | ICMPmarketing0 -
Penguin 4.0 update: drop in results end of September
Has anyone noticed certain drops in keyword rankings on/around 29 September? Has this to do with the Penguin 4.0 update? I read that this hasn't come "bug-free". Will this be adjusted the upcoming weeks? Or is this drop content-based based on the new algorithms and the content needs to be adjusted/updated?
Reporting & Analytics | | Mikrocentrum0 -
How do i know that my website affected by Panda Updates ?
If website is affected by Panda updates then how do we know that? If have any type of tools or strategies or alert to find out affected website by Panda then update as soon as possible.
Reporting & Analytics | | renukishor0 -
When Penguins Attack...
I'm hoping for a couple of second opinions of my conclusions here before I shoot 60% of our link profile in the head...
Reporting & Analytics | | WorldText
a) I've not needed to deal with an angry Penguin before,
b) it's not as black and white as most of the blog posts seem to find. Domain is www.world-text.com The Penguin Google Says... ● We have no unnatural links warning in WMT
● We have dropped out of the top 50 for all keywords except three. Those three are a couple of pages down.
● We still own page 1 for a brand search (World Text), though we lost the bottom result.
● Overall traffic down 25%, organic down 50%, SERPs impressions down 50-70% I'd love to know where the remaining organic Google traffic is coming from as we currently rank for nothing (useful anyway); the analytics doesn't show the usual off a cliff to nothing, more a few quiet weeks. Several other players in the sector appear to have been obliterated too - searches on several keywords are a total mess with total unknowns and spam showing up on page 1 SERPs. Adwords traffic is up markedly which I put down to the mess that is SERPs Our adwords are nicely optimised and our top keywords are hitting quality scores of >=8, mostly 9 or 10. Why did the Penguin Peck?... Simple. Opensiteexplorer should make it blindingly obvious what the issue is. We have a horrible link profile that I have been muttering about for 18 months or more. ● Long before I joined seems they got a 5,000 search friendly directory submissions package or equivalent
● Sadly not a single one of them was from the long obsolete SEOMoz directories list, or worth keeping.
● Every single last one of them has identical anchor text and description. Still, makes for easy analysis.
● The anchor text used isn't likely to be searched often
"World-Text.com Text Messaging Services"
● 3 of 4 originally submitted sites/directories have since expired, removed links etc Findings 740 judged bad domains:
All the identical anchor text SEO directories
a couple of others picked out as unwanted
the domains serving malware Only 235 class Cs in these
144 have 0-2 indexed pages - not useful for a directory! 500 judged maybe:
No links found even though in WMT (a lot of these)
down, suspended etc (a lot of these too)
parked
links that are less than ideal but not identically anchored spam.
(for instance someone who had linked to us has had their site scraped and dropped on dozen or more forums including our link) another pass of these in a week or so, just in case some come back to life... 400 judged good (well harmless):
Natural links
real directories
all the assorted alexa like scrapers, domain valuation junk etc. Executing Penguins and other vermin... Apparently pretending to know nothing doesn't help, so... ● Disavow the three discovered sites serving malware
● Remove where possible every last one of the SEO directory entries avoiding any extorted payment. Track contacts and responses.
● Disavow the rest {Reconsideration request} I KNOW this is for manual penalties, and we don't have one, BUT I've seen countless sources suggesting reconsideration for Penguin. Really? Anyway that was far longer than intended, so thanks for making it this far! I look forward to comments!0 -
Hit by a penalty... but which one?!
Hi all, One of our sites has seen a huge drop in traffic beginning in January 2012 and continuing to this day. However, even after spending a great deal of time going through analytics I'm none of the wiser to what penalty has caused the drop in traffic (please see attached - grey line is minus one year). The problem is that our traffic is particularly seasonal, hence the difficulty in highlighting what algorithm update(s) has hit us. I'm tearing my hair out with this one, so any advice would be most appreciated! Cheers yxkTnTn
Reporting & Analytics | | dooberry0 -
Are Panda/Penguin Penalties not Global but only fired for specific Google CCTLDs?
An international portfolio of web sites has been suffering from Panda and Penguin over the last months. Essentially many of the international sites completely disappeared from the top 50 when before we had many Top 5 positions for competitive key words. Today we noticed that it appears that for all this time rankings for local keywords have not been affected for domains outside of the most relevant Google CCTLD for the page. To give an example: Domain.it / Keyword 1 (IT) = Italian Competitive Keyword Google.it: Keyword 1 (IT) April 2012 Position 4
Reporting & Analytics | | sp80
Google.it: Keyword 1 (IT) December 2012 Position --- Google.com: Keyword 1 (IT) April 2012 Position 1
Google.com: Keyword 1 (IT) December 2012 Position 1 Google.de: Keyword 1 (IT) April 2012 Position 3
Google.de: Keyword 1 (IT) December 2012 Position 4 Have other people observed such behavior? Does this give any pointers towards how the recovery strategies should be drafted? We have experienced that the more search volume a keywords has received the harder the Panda/Penguin impact. So one hypothesis could be that because the international Google domains do not receive overly significant traffic for the localized keywords Panda/Penguin protection algorithms are not being applied with the same force. Any thoughts are welcome. /Thomas1 -
If a page bounces in the woods, can Google Panda hear it?
I have read that after the Panda update a site's bounce rate is an important ranking metric. However, can anyone confirm whether all pages count equally? For instance, my home page gets 5000% more traffic than Deep Page X. If Deep Page X has a poor bounce rate, does it matter as much as if my Homepage has a bad bounce rate? I am guessing not, but wanted to open it up for discussion. If not, it has me wondering on what to do for some of my database driven content. I have some dynamically created pages that have higher bounce rates and minimal unique content. They aren't pure spam or junk, but are likely only about 1% unique from one another. Sounds like a no brainer change post-Panda, right? Well, what if I was the only one targeting the keywords for these pages? The pages pull from info I stored on the U.S. government stimulus program (related to my industry). It then has just about every city, state and county combo in the country for my product. For instance, a page <title>might be "Flemington, NJ Widgets - Somerset County". Something that no one else is targeting and drives minimal traffic.</p> <p> </p> <p>Do I take this content down? I didn't have any affects, positive or negative from Panda, so I am hesitant to take down thousands of Google cached pages.</p></title>
Reporting & Analytics | | TheDude0