Is LittleBlackDress.co.uk under penalty?
-
They are a client who has been hit pretty hard by Penguin 2.0 after we were just starting to grow in April. I am getting different opinions from SEO different agencies and I'd rather ask "the Moz community"
-
Thanks Tom,
I think we have a similar school of thought to that. We will continue to add good quality links and go for high authority links over a sustained period of time.
Unfortunately we worked with a bad SEO provider in the past who claimed "Google moved the goalposts" - this is utter none-sense as they just used spammy tactics for their clients to make money. In many ways I'm glad Google have updated their algorithm to be more sophisticated as it is rewarding the better SEO's & Link builders.
Eventually I think those bad links that are still in our profile will be diluted and we will remove them as I think they will negatively affect us at some point in the future i.e. "Panda 3.0" but that might be a few months off yet.
Cheers for the advice
Paul
-
You could ask 50 SEOs this question and get 50 different answers - simply because Penguin case studies and definitive guides are pretty much non-existent.
Is it a cop-out to say: "You need to both?"
Part of me thinks: if you're under an algorithmic penalty - so long as the algorithm sees those bad links in your profile you will always have the algorithm's effect on the site. So by that logic, you'd want to remove all the bad links.
But then we need to remember - this is an algorithm. Has it seen some of the bad links but not classed them as "spammy/bad"? Those blog comments for instance, has the algorithm taken them into account? Or even registered them?
The point is that if you remove or disavow these spammy links, you could see your ranking decrease further, as they could be powering up your site still. With your traffic and keywords recovering somewhat, this might not be a thing you want to do.
If a gun was put to my head - I'd go on the notion that removing or disavowing all of the bad links would be the most definitive way of removing the algorithmic penalty completely from your site. However, all of those links would need to be replaced and I'm also living in a "perfect world" scenario. Many people are sceptical over whether a completely recovery is even possible and if using the disavow tool is pretty much like opening up to crimes before Google.
It's just so hard to judge. Looking at what's happening right now - I'd continue with the route of adding high quality and authoritative links to your site and monitor keyword and traffic progression. If it keeps recovering - great. If, eventually. the progression halts for a few months and won't improve no matter what you do - and you are not at a traffic or keyword level that you would be happy with - I'd then maybe look at the remaining bad links and say "you know what - you're holding us back now more than you (potentially) may be benefiting us. We're gonna get rid of you." Be completely thorough at this stage.
You'll probably see a rankings dip, but hopefully by resuming the healthy link building process you can reach new heights, which would hopefully vindicate the decision.
Hope this helps!
-
Hi Tom,
Thanks for the feedback, this is very useful, especially the http://www.barracuda-digital.co.uk/panguin-tool/ tool.
We have been trying to remove a large number of the bad links but it seems we need to continue in this process. Can we just continue to build good links to de-spam our overall profile or do all the bad links need to be removed?
Since the recent refresh by Google on Friday 12th July, we have noticed an increase in traffic and the keyword rankings that were negatively effected have started to improve.
We think we need to continue to improve the % of good links to the site but I feel this might be too simplistic.
-
Hi Paul
Would it be possible for you to run the website through this free tool? http://www.barracuda-digital.co.uk/panguin-tool/
It coincides your organic traffic levels with major Google updates, so you may be able to see on the first Penguin refresh of the new algorithm whether or not the traffic fell with it. Correlation does not necessarily equal causation, but if there is a drop around the time of the update, it could well be a Penguin penalty.
Worth noting that the new Penguin algorithm looks to be having a stagnated effect on the SERPs - not like the previous update/aftermath/carry on system of old. So your traffic drop may not coincide with the update on that tool, but the site could still be effected by the algorithm.
Looking at the site's backlinks - there's definitely some evidence that would suggest a penalty could be problem. Comment spam, such as here, and here looks to make up a large portion of the backlinks to the website. There is also quite a lot of commercial, exact match anchor text links as well, which could be a problem.
Hope this helps.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Does anyone have experience with Simplilearn?
I want to hear the opinion of other Marketers My main goal is found a place where I can get an integral knowledge, not just SEO or PPC or whatever. Simplilearn offers a Master Program called "Digital Marketing Specialist"
Industry News | | Roman-Delcarmen
Which cover this areas Advanced Web Analytics
- Advanced Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
- Advanced Pay Per Click (PPC)
- Advanced Social Media But also they have available other related topics such as Email Marketing Conversion Rate Optimization I know there are some ones that are mandatory and FREE
and for me this are not a big deal, because all the documentation
is available for everyone Google Analytics > Data Analytics
Facebook Blue Print > Data Analytics
Google Adwords > PPC
Bing > PPC I will make the certifciation
But Im looking for something with better level
Such as "Integreted Marketing Campaign"1 -
Community Discussion: The hardest (& most surprisingly valuable) thing you've gone through for your SEO career?
In the comment discussion for Thursday's blog post, An Essential Training Task List for Junior SEOs, there's been mild debate around some of the items, such as having a Junior SEO build a website by hand. It's a fantastic comment discussion (the kind that makes a blog manager's heart sing), and it's got me thinking. We've all gone through the wringer when it comes to boosting our careers. Heck, I was a poetry major and found myself learning SQL last week. What hurdles have you jumped that have been painful and challenging, but have taken your career to the finish line? Maybe even gotten you the gold?* What would you recommend to newbies just starting out (or warn them about)? *Yeah, I got Olympic about it. I went there. 🙂
Industry News | | FeliciaCrawford6 -
Google penalty removal expert questions
We have searched online for a Google penalty “expert” (individual or company) and have located what appear to be “experts”. Please provide feedback on the following 2 individuals/companies we have found that can help with penalty removal. Have you or one of your clients used either of the “experts” below? What were the results? How many disavows and reconsideration requests did you/they have to make? 1.www.penaltypros.com . To give a quote and to see what your links are they use links from Google Webmaster Tools only. Penaltypros.com disavows first and then removes bad links second. This is opposite of what Google and Seo’s recommend but penaltypros.com claims 100% success using this non-traditional approach. See imgur.com link for screenshot. 2.http://www.hiswebmarketing.com/ To give a quote and to see what your links are they use links from https://ahrefs.com/ only. Please provide any and all feedback on the above 2 “experts” and also post the websites, individual names, company names of those that you consider Google penalty removal “experts” so that we may obtain a quote from them. Lp9F3FI
Industry News | | RetractableAwnings.com1 -
Spanish equivalent of MOZ? need help with understanding Google.es
I try to keep up to date with everything SEO to ensure my sites rank well.. marblerenovation.com & Trailersafe.co.uk I now have a spanish site that I am having trouble ranking well for clima2000egara.es I have recently found out (by asking our lovely moz community) that googles algorithms are not rolled our world wide. SO I have no idea where I am at with Google.es. Does anyone know how I can find out at what stage google.es is at? and what the last update was? and whether there is an equilalent community like Moz for Spain? I am fluent spanish so the language won't be a problem.. Thanks in advance for all your help
Industry News | | david.smith.segarra0 -
Manual action penalty by Google
Hello, We have a big well-known brand - www.titanbet.com. This brand is well established and the site has been live for almost 4 years now ranking very well on some very strong KWs. we received a message from Google on Aug 29<sup>th</sup> saying “Google has detected a pattern of artificial or unnatural links pointing to your site” and that “Google has applied a manual spam action to titanbet.com/” The past 2 weeks since the penalty was received we saw some of our major KWs drop in rankings. BUT all brand related KWs were still ranked 1<sup>st</sup> Over the last weekend the penalty has worsen and we no longer rank on any of the brands KWs (we find the site in 5<sup>th</sup> page at best). Moreover, when searching for a sentence from the any of the page on the site in Google, we see other sites ahead of us in the SERPs. Based on the message we originally received from Google we have started cleaning some of the bad links to the site. We found a lot of links from bad sites, some of them are not indexed and probably penalized as well, some are from affiliate websites and some are from some automatic indexation websites based in China and Russia
Industry News | | Tit
we have started reaching out to some of these sites to try and have them remove our links. We are also worried about the duplication of our site. We have found many other sites (mostly affiliate websites) have copied and in some cases completely duplicated our content. Google for some reason has chosen to penalize us for this. Although we do not have control over these other sites. We have run copyscape to try and figure out which pages are the most problematic and we will try to re-write the content on these pages. But what if the other sites copy us again? Any suggestions on the above would be appreciated as we try to understand why Google has penalized us. thank you Titan Bet Team0 -
Any recommendation for UK based hosting company?
Hi everyone, I am looking for a good hosting company for my site and clients sites. I need shared hosting not dedicated one. I ve been using 1&1 , they are great but their server is in Germany. So I believe its not good for SEO. So I need a company whose server is in UK. Thanks in advance.
Industry News | | Jorenr0 -
UK link building companies?
Has anyone had any experience working with any? Are there any you'd particularly recommend/avoid? Thanks. 🙂
Industry News | | Alex-Harford0 -
How to remove a Google algorithmic penalty
My site has a Google penalty. I seem to be stuck in the 64th position for a Google search for my sites name. All my keywords that I used to rank well for are now well above the 60th search place in Google. I have resolved the issue I recieved the penalty for and I have asked Google for reconsideration. That has been about 3 months ago. The penalty is still firmly in place. I was wondering if anyone else has had a Google algorithmic penalty removed and if so how did they accomplish this?
Industry News | | tadden0