Webmaster Tools finding phantom 404s?
-
We recently (three months now!) switched over a site from .co.uk to .com and all old urls are re-directing to the new site.
However, Google Webmaster tools is flagging up hundreds of 404s from the old site and yet doesn't report where the links were found, i.e. in the 'Linked From' tab there is no data and the old links are not in the sitemap.
SEOmoz crawls do not report any 404s.
Any ideas?
-
Okay, thanks, and you are quite right, a whole morning is more than enough energy... gotta love SEO work!!!!
-
OK, well if it truly doesn't make sense (does sound odd, and it does seem like you've done the redirects fine) and three months is more than long enough for GWT to have caught up I'd take the above approach and periodically download the 404 list and seeing if there are any additions, as well as seeing if maybe Bing Webmaster Tools agrees with GWT.
If everything is redirecting fine, then I'd be inclined to just disregard it for the time being and focus my energies elsewhere. Good luck with it!
-
Maybe temporarily stop the 301 on the old site. Re-run your crawl reports and see if there were any 404s in existence on the old site that you hadn't previously thought. Plug the links and then reinstate the 301?
Either that or, if you're sure there's no problem, download the phantom 404s to CSV and then only take note of additions to that list in future?
-
That's the strange thing, all urls on the .co.uk are 301'ing to the new site.
-
If you can't tell where the links are coming from then the next bet is as Ben said is to identify the URLs which are being linked to and 301 them to a page which is closely related (or the home page otherwise), that way you don't lose any potential visitors to your site via those links.
-
Webmaster is picking up 494 pages returning a 404 and yet Roger Bot is finding none, so I can't even identify where the links are coming from. This is the part that is confusing me.
If I try and access any of the pages reported in the list, I am simply re-directed to the new site, as we are re-directing all .co.uk pages to the .com
-
I've had similar experiences after migrating sites over to a new CMS. The links are being picked up from somewhere so the best thing to do is create a 301 redirect if there is a valuable similar page to the 404. The only other option is to lose possible link juice from where ever the link is coming from. It's always better to have a pure link (no 301) but if you can't contact the original link then there is nothing you can do.
I'm curious as to where the links come from as well. Maybe someone will be able to speak to that.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Switched from and HTTPS to HTTP. My home page is facing a redirect issue from the http to https. Should I no index the HTTP or find the redirect and delete it? Thank you
Switched from and HTTPS to HTTP. My home page is facing a redirect issue from the http to https. Should I no index the HTTP or find the redirect and delete it? Thank you
Technical SEO | | LandmarkRecovery20170 -
Keyword cannibalisation - Any way to find out who is eating who?
I have a question regarding some keywords in my site. For some reason, I am ranking for the wrong keyword in some SERPs or my top page is ranking instead. Example: graphic design is ranking for web design Is there any tool or way to figure out how, why or who is eating each other up so to speak? Would you have any advice or links to good sources on how to resolve this issue so that the correct page shows in search for it's particular keyword? Thanks in advance!
Technical SEO | | Kuruto0 -
Remove Directory In Webmaster Tools
Hey Moz'erz, I'm removing some URLS from the index and want to confirm the use of the "remove directory" request. If my structure is this: /blogs/customer-success-stories/tagged/ --- all pages that are /tagged/abc, /tagged/dce etc. will be removed correct? First time trying a directory removal as their are 100 plus of these tagged pages. Comments, suggestions and past experiences welcome!
Technical SEO | | paul-bold0 -
Web Master Tools: change of address
Hello, Hope you can help with an issue I'm having:www.brand-kw1-kw2.com (eg name of course) has moved to www.brand.comAll settings are done - like I did before when moving and setting up a new domain for an older site. (30q redirects - all versions are verified in WMT).However, when the change of adress features is "called out" I get the message: "We couldn't verify www.brand-kw1-kw2.com To submit a change of address, www.brand-kw1-kw2.com must be verified using the same method as brand-kw1-kw2.com. Add www.brand-kw1-kw2.com to your account and verify ownership, then try again." So dose it basically saying that I have to use the same method to verify both the www and non-www version ? Dose it make sense ? It sounds silly. Again, all version are verified and visibile in WMT already - I don't know how in the past those verifications were done but everything is looking good now. Is here a fix for this issue ? (I've moved several but this is the first issue I've encountered) Many thanks.
Technical SEO | | eyepaq0 -
How do crawl errors from SEOmoz tool set effect rankings?
Hello - The other day I presented the crawl diagnostic report to a client. We identified duplicate page title errors, missing meta description errors, and duplicate content errors. After reviewing the report we presented it to the clients web company who operates a closed source CMS. Their response was that these errors are not worthy of fixing and in fact they are not hurting the site. We are having issues getting the errors fixed and I would like your opinion on this matter. My question is, how bad are these errors? Should we not fix them? Should they be fixed? Will fixing the errors have an impact on our site's rankings? Personally, I think the question is silly. I mean, the errors were found using the SEOmoz tool kit, these errors have to be effecting SEO.....right? The attached image is the result of the Crawl Diagnostics that crawled 1,400 pages. NOTE: Most of the errors are coming from Pages like blog/archive/2011-07/page-2 /blog/category/xxxxx-xxxxxx-xxxxxxx/page-2 testimonials/147/xxxxx--xxxxx (xxxx represents information unique to the client) Thanks for your insight! c9Q33.png
Technical SEO | | Gabe0 -
Number of Indexed Pages in Webmaster Tools
My # of indexed pages in Webmaster Tools fluctuates greatly. Compared to the # of URLs submitted (4700), we have 3000 indexed. The other day, all 4700 were indexed. Why does it keep changing? I obviously want all of them indexed right? What can I do to make that happen?
Technical SEO | | kylesuss0 -
Google Webmaster Creation
When creating Google Webmaster Account is it advised to create 2 accounts for the 1 domain. one for non www and one for www?
Technical SEO | | daracreative0 -
Crawl Errors In Webmaster Tools
Hi Guys, Searched the web in an answer to the importance of crawl errors in Webmaster tools but keep coming up with different answers. I have been working on a clients site for the last two months and (just completed one months of link bulding), however seems I have inherited issues I wasn't aware of from the previous guy that did the site. The site is currently at page 6 for the keyphrase 'boiler spares' with a keyword rich domain and a good onpage plan. Over the last couple of weeks he has been as high as page 4, only to be pushed back to page 8 and now settled at page 6. The only issue I can seem to find with the site in webmaster tools is crawl errors here are the stats:- In sitemaps : 123 Not Found : 2,079 Restricted by robots.txt 1 Unreachable: 2 I have read that ecommerce sites can often give off false negatives in terms of crawl errors from Google, however, these not found crawl errors are being linked from pages within the site. How have others solved the issue of crawl errors on ecommerce sites? could this be the reason for the bouncing round in the rankings or is it just a competitive niche and I need to be patient? Kind Regards Neil
Technical SEO | | optimiz10